Canoes vs Kayaks – Which one is the right choice for you?
If you are new to paddling, then trying to choose between a canoe and a kayak can be a rather daunting task; not to mention confusing since the terminology tends to differ from country to country.
- Canoes vs Kayaks – Which one is the right choice for you?
- Parts of a Canoe – Plan View
- Parts of a Canoe – Side View
- Kayak types can be further sub-dived into:
- Recreational Canoes
- Square Stern Canoes
- Whitewater Canoes
- Racing Canoes
- Parts of a Kayak – Plan View
- Sit Inside Kayaks
- Sit On Top Kayaks
- Inflatable Kayaks
- Recreational Kayaks
- Whitewater Kayaks
- Surf Kayaks
- Day Touring Kayaks
- Expedition Kayaks
- Racing Kayaks
- Advantages of a Canoe
- Disadvantages of a Canoe
- Advantages of a Kayak
- Disadvantages of a Kayak
- How important is speed to you?
- How important is stability to you?
- How important is manoeuvrability to you?
- How important is load capacity to you?
- What type of water will you be paddling on most often?
- Will you be frequently entering and exiting your paddlecraft?
What is a Canoe & What is a Kayak?
Let’s Clear any Confusion:
Americans use the term “canoe” to describe a paddlecraft with an open deck and the seats positioned level with, or, just below, the gunwale (aka gunnel); and the term “kayak” to refer to a paddlecraft with a closed deck and a seat that is positioned adjacent to the bilge (the interior bottom of the hull).
Both Canadians and Brits refer to a canoe as a “Canadian canoe” and to a kayak as a “canoe”. However, regardless of the terminology that you use to designate each type of paddlecraft, the advantages and disadvantages of each type of paddlecraft are the same.
The confusion does not stop there because there are several different classes of both canoes and kayaks and each type is specifically designed for a different purpose. So, what are the main differences between canoes and kayaks?
Well, to begin with, canoes have what is commonly referred to as an “open cockpit” (the place where the paddler or paddlers sit) and gunwales (the upper edge of a ship or boat’s side) that are positioned well above the waterline. While kayaks have a “closed cockpit” and gunwales that are positioned a very short distance above the waterline.
Also, as mentioned above, canoes commonly have two bench-like seats that are fixed to the sides of the cockpit so that when a paddler sits in a canoe, their posterior is positioned level with or, just below, the gunwale with their feet resting flat against the bilge as if they were sitting in a chair.
Whereas kayaks commonly have either a molded composite or plastic seat positioned just above the bilge which forces the paddler to extend their legs out in front of them with their feet resting against a pair of adjustable foot pegs, and their knees resting against the underside of the front deck which aids the paddler in manoeuvring the craft.
Parts of a Canoe – Plan View
- STERN DECK
- STERN SEAT
- STERN THWART
- MIDSHIP THWART
- BOW THWART
- BOW SEAT
- BOW DECK
Parts of a Canoe – Side View
- WATERLINE LENGTH
What is Rocker on a Canoe
- HIGH ROCKER
- MODERATE ROCKER
Last but not least, each type of paddlecraft is commonly propelled with a different type of paddle.
Canoeist most often use a single bladed paddle and either move the paddle from one side of the canoe to the other, or, they use something called a “J stroke” to keep the canoe traveling in a straight line.
Typical Canoe Paddle Shape
Typical Kayak Paddle Shape
Kayakers commonly use a double-bladed paddle which they use to paddle first on one side of their craft and then on the other without having to move the paddle across the cockpit.
To muddy the water even further, there are four different categories of canoes and three different categories of kayaks.
Kayaks are further sub-divided into seven different types.
Types of Canoes
- Recreational canoes
- Square Stern Canoes
- Whitewater canoes
- Racing canoes
Types of Kayaks
- Sit-inside kayaks
- Sit-on-top kayaks
- Inflatable kayaks
Kayak types can be further sub-dived into:
- Recreational kayaks
- Day touring kayaks
- Expedition kayaks
- Whitewater kayaks
- Surf kayaks
- Surf skis
- Racing kayaks
So, at this point, you are probably wondering what the differences are between all of these different types of paddlecraft, so let’s start with canoes.
What are the Differences Between the Types of Canoes?
To begin with, recreational canoes are commonly between 13 ft. and 17 ft. long and are designed to have a high degree of initial stability as well as to be easy for the paddler or paddlers to control and because of this are the most common type of canoe chosen for paddling on lakes, ponds and, slow moving rivers. These are equally good canoes for families as they are for one person canoes.
Square Stern Canoes
Square stern canoes are built with a flat rear to accommodate a motor if so desired. These are a good idea if you’re going on an extended trip when the gentle output from a small trolling motor can give you a well-earned rest from paddling.
Whitewater canoes on the other hand, are often significantly shorter than recreational canoes and have a higher degree of rocker in order to make them more manoeuvrable, but, they are far more difficult to paddle in a straight line. In addition, they generally have a much lower degree of initial stability than recreational canoes in order to enable the paddler to lean them on their chines. They are generally outfitted with air-filled floatation bags to prevent water from filling the cockpit and sinking the craft.
Racing canoes differ from both recreational and whitewater canoes in that they are much more narrow in order to present less wetted surface area for increased speed, and they sit lower in the water to help compensate for the lack of initial stability. Plus, they generally lack bench seats and instead, the paddler or paddlers kneel in the bilge, which increases their initial stability.
Parts of a Kayak – Plan View
- Carry Handle
- Geck lines
- Thigh braces
Types of Kayaks
As mentioned above, not only are there three different categories of kayaks, there are seven different types that are all designed for specific purposes.
Sit Inside Kayaks
As the name implies, sit-inside kayaks have the classic closed cockpit with a seat that is positioned adjacent to the bilge
Sit On Top Kayaks
whereas sit-on-top kayaks have open cockpits just like a canoe does and, the same is true of inflatable kayaks (below).
But, this is where kayak classification gets complicated, because while sit-on-top and inflatable kayaks are both classified as recreational kayaks, there are seven different types of sit-inside kayaks consisting of recreational kayaks, whitewater kayaks, surf kayaks, day touring kayaks, expedition kayaks, surf skis and, racing kayaks.
Recreational kayaks are generally rather wide in order to provide paddlers with a high degree of initial stability and rather short to make them highly manoeuvrable.
Both sit-on-top and inflatable kayaks are considered to be recreational kayaks.
Similar to recreational kayaks, most whitewater kayaks are sit-inside designs that are also rather short, but, their hulls have a much higher degree of rocker in order to make them even more manoeuvrable.
Next, there are surf kayaks which, at first glance, often appear to be very similar to whitewater kayaks but which have hulls that are specifically designed for surfing waves.
Day Touring Kayaks
Day Touring Kayaks on the other hand are often available in both sit-inside and sit-on-top designs and, they are generally significantly longer than whitewater kayaks in order to provide the paddler with more speed for paddling over longer distances. Plus, they have less rocker in order to better enable them to travel in a straight line (called tracking) with less effort. Day touring kayaks are most often chosen for medium range padding excursions.
Next we have expedition kayaks, and as the name implies, are specifically designed for long range paddling excursions as well as for kayak camping. All expedition kayaks are sit-inside designs, they are generally longer and wider than day touring kayaks with more internal volume and sealed bulkheads. This provides both extra dry storage space for camping gear, food, and fresh water, as well as additional floatation.
Last but not least, there are two different types of racing kayaks consisting of sit-inside designs which are simply called “racing kayaks” and “surf skis” which are all sit-on-top designs. However, both types are much longer and much narrower than either day touring or expedition kayaks and they have a significantly higher degree of rocker. Both types are much faster than day touring or expedition kayaks but, they are also far less stable. They generally require a rudder to keep them traveling in a straight line despite their length.
So, now that you have a basic understanding of the different types of canoes and kayaks, you might be wondering what the pros and cons to each type of paddlecraft are, so we’ve listed these below:
Canoe and kayak pros and cons:
Advantages of a Canoe
- Canoes are generally more stable than kayaks due to their width.
- Canoes are easier to enter and exit than kayaks.
- Canoes have a much higher load capacity than kayaks and so can carry more gear.
- You get a better view of your surroundings in a canoe than you do in a kayak due to the higher seating position.
- Solo portaging (by-passing sections of water via land) regularly is much easier in a canoe than in a kayak because it’s easier to unload and reload your gear.
Disadvantages of a Canoe
- Canoes have open cockpits, which expose the paddler to sun, wind, and spray.
- Canoes have less efficient hull designs than kayaks and so require more effort to paddle.
- Canoes are less manoeuvrable than kayaks and so require more effort to turn.
- Canoes often weigh more than kayaks and therefore require more effort to transport.
Advantages of a Kayak
- Kayaks have more efficient hull designs than canoes and so require less effort to paddle.
- Kayaks are more manoeuvrable than canoes and so require less effort to turn.
- Most kayaks are lighter than most canoes, which makes them easier to transport.
- Sit-inside kayaks have closed cockpits, which protect the paddler from sun, wind, and spray.
- Sit-inside kayaks have dry storage holds.
- Sit-inside kayaks can be rolled upright after a capsize.
Disadvantages of a Kayak
- Kayaks are less stable than canoes, this makes them more prone to capsize.
- Kayaks are more difficult to enter and exit than canoes.
- Kayaks have a much lower load capacity than canoes, they cannot carry as much gear.
Canoes vs Kayaks: Which to Choose?
So, as you can see, not only are there several types of canoes and kayaks designed for different purposes, they each have many different pros and cons.
So, which type of paddle craft is best for you?
Well, the answer to that question really depends on your personal preferences. If you are new to the sport of paddling and are still undecided on which type of paddle craft to choose, read on as there are a few things that you should keep in mind such as:
How important is speed to you?
If you are one of those people who prefer to glide across the water with a minimum of effort while covering long distances during the course of the day, then a kayak is a better choice.
How important is stability to you?
If you are one of those paddlers who is intimidated by the idea of capsizing, then a canoe is a better choice.
How important is manoeuvrability to you?
If you plan on exploring convoluted coastlines and/or entering creeks, or paddling in swamps, marshes or bayous, then a kayak is a better choice.
How important is load capacity to you?
If you are one of those paddlers who doesn’t mind traveling at a slower pace as long as you have plenty of room for all of your camping gear and/or a fellow paddler or a paddling companion, then a canoe is a better choice.
What type of water will you be paddling on most often?
If you plan on paddling on calm water most often, then a canoe can be a better choice for you. But, if you plan on padding on large lakes, or bays where the wind can cause the water to become rough or, if you plan on paddling in the surf, then a kayak is a better choice.
Will you be frequently entering and exiting your paddlecraft?
If you are one of those paddlers who plans on entering and exiting their paddlecraft frequently during the day to explore land features, or to portage from one body of water to another, then a canoe is a better choice.
So, as mentioned above, the choice between a canoe and a kayak really comes down to personal choice since they both have advantages and disadvantages that cause paddlers to choose one type of paddlecraft over the other.
It is important to carefully consider what type of water you will be paddling on most often as well as to contemplate your answers to the questions listed above so that you can choose the type of paddlecraft that best suits your intended purpose.
Regardless of which type of paddlecraft you choose, paddling is a great way to get outdoors and have fun on the water during the warmer months of the year as well as to explore local bodies of water.